Phoenicia Diner Menu (Update 2025)
Introducing Phoenicia Diner, a popular spot in the Catskills known for its extensive menu and welcoming atmosphere. Located at 5681 Sr 28 Phoenicia, NY 12464, this diner offers a range of options such as fluffy buttermilk pancakes, Veggie Reuben Sandwich, Arnold Bennett Skillet, and Mt. Tremper omelet. Customers rave about the fantastic service and consistently great food, highlighting favorites like the Full Phoenicia Breakfast, Buttermilk Pancakes, and Carne asada Mac and cheese burrito. The vintage-modern vibe, gender-neutral restrooms, outdoor seating with a food truck extension, and a variety of payment options including cryptocurrency and Apple Pay make Phoenicia Diner a must-visit. Don't miss out on their specialty dishes like the Arnold Bennett Skillet and the seasonal apple cider pancakes for a truly delightful dining experience.
Cocktails
Bootlegger Toddy
Catskill most righteous bourbon, hot cinnamon tea, schoolhouse maple syrup
Butterfly Margarita
Sauza, orange liqueur, lime juice, butterfly pea flower tea
Schultz Spritz
Union grove vly vodka, maya's plum cinnamon, lemon juice, prosecco
Mickey The Gent
Catskill rye, maya's pear ginger, lime juice, ginger beer
Hibiscus Paloma
Ilegal joven mezcal, hibiscus tea, agave, grapefruit, lime juice, selzer
Bloody Mary
Vly creek vodka, slurry, migliorelli tomato juice
Mimosa
Prosecco, fresh orange juice
Michelada
Xx amber, fresh lime, slurry
Xx
Pacifico
Sunday Everyday Lager
Arrowood Trickster Dark Lager
Crossroads Black Rock Stout
Abandoned Vacation Cider
Arrowood Polly
Rare Form Troy Division Ipa
Key Lime Pie Gose
West Kill Brookie
oz
Beer
Canned Wine
Crafters Union Red Blend
Beach Juice Rose
Merf Chardonnay
Merf Cabernet
Coppola Pinot Noir
Bourbon Milkshake
Catskill distilling most righteous bourbon
Sugar Shack Shake
Catskill distilling most righteous bourbon, ronnybrook vanilla, local maple syrup, ginger, cinnamon, nutmeg
Whistle In The Dark Shake
Black seal rum, orgeat, mayas plum cinnamon, ronnybrook chocolate